Fairway 74th Street Cafe

Nestled on the second floor of the Fairway supermarket at 2131 Broadway, Fairway 74th Street Cafe offers a bright and casual dining experience that effortlessly blends the intimacy of a neighborhood diner with the vibrant energy of the Upper West Side. This cafe is a treasure trove for breakfast and lunch lovers looking for quality, comfort, and thoughtful culinary flair in one convenient location.

The menu showcases a diverse range of American classics elevated with fresh ingredients and generous portions. Whether you're craving the hearty Breakfast Platter or indulging in the buttery, fluffy Buttermilk Pancakes drizzled with 100% Vermont Maple Syrup, every dish is crafted to awaken your senses. The Hot Honey Chicken Sandwich delivers a perfect balance of heat and sweetness, while the Prime Beef options, like the juicy Spicy Steak Sandwich or the classic French Dip, promise satisfying and savory flavors that linger delightfully on the palate.

Beyond breakfast staples, the cafe impresses with more refined choices such as the Spring Salad bursting with fresh garden notes, the richly earthy Wild Mushroom dish, and the elegant American Rib Lamb Chops that feel indulgent yet approachable. For those seeking lighter fare, the Fruit Plate and the crisp Grilled Artichokes offer refreshing alternatives.

What truly sets Fairway 74th Street Cafe apart is its inviting atmosphere and attentive service. The second-floor location overlooks bustling Broadway, creating an energized yet comfortable space perfect for a quick morning boost or a casual midday meal. Customers frequently praise the warm, genuine attentiveness of the waitstaff—Jivan, for example, is noted for being both efficient and friendly—while chefs like Jerry add elegant touches, such as meticulously diced cucumbers in salads, that reflect a thoughtful approach to each plate.

Regular patrons echo the sentiment that the cafe strikes an ideal balance between quality and value. With coffees like the expertly crafted cortado and sizeable portions like the challah French toast, it's clear this spot doesn’t compromise flavor or experience, even if the setting leans toward functional rather than lounging. Carol Mills’s glowing review of the “best omelette in the city” and Theresa C’s delighted recommendation of the authentic avocado toast illustrate the cafe’s consistent ability to please diverse palates.

Whether you're grabbing a cup of robust coffee to fuel your day, savoring a perfectly cooked Steak and Eggs, or soaking in the views with a large cappuccino and a seasonal salad, Fairway 74th Street Cafe invites you to enjoy familiar favorites with a touch of thoughtful refinement. It’s a reliable gem on the Upper West Side, ideal for solo diners, friends, or families seeking delicious food in a friendly, bright setting.

For a taste of New York comfort food with subtle gourmet sensibilities, alongside welcoming service and vibrant cityscape views, Fairway 74th Street Cafe is a must-visit destination.